Exploring AI’s impact on the Legal System

Science fiction has often depicted AI as the future's dominant force, but replacing human judges with software is now becoming a reality. Recent unofficial experiments have seen judges from various countries, including Colombia, Pakistan, India, and Bolivia, turning to AI, particularly ChatGPT, for guidance in legal cases. For example, in China, AI is already being utilized to advise and assist judges, a trend likely to continue. While advantageous in expediting legal processes, this approach has several fundamental flaws.

Firstly, AI functions either as an expert system (which has proven ineffective on a large scale) or a machine learning system. The latter, although powerful in finding correlations in data, often reaches inaccurate conclusions. Additionally, AI can produce false information, potentially leading to catastrophic consequences in legal proceedings. AI cannot replace human lawyers due to its limitations and inaccuracies. Historical data used by machine learning systems can perpetuate biases and prejudices against individuals in underrepresented groups.

Translating legal rules into reliable software rules is a challenging task, and AI judgments may be incorrect due to differing interpretations among programmers. Automated government systems can also have disastrous consequences, as demonstrated by the Dutch and Australian governments' automated systems, which wrongly accused families of fraud, impacting hundreds of thousands of welfare recipients, respectively.

Finally, the complex tasks that judges perform, such as caseload handling and team supervision, would be difficult to replicate using software programs. Therefore, while using AI in the legal system may seem appealing, its limitations, biases, and difficulties in translation make it unsuitable as a substitute for human judges. As technology continues to evolve, it is essential to proceed with caution and ensure that AI is implemented in a way that upholds fairness, transparency, and justice.

If you want to read the article written by Rónán Kennedy, please click in the link below:

https://n9.cl/3r7sw

‍